I just finished reading Best Destiny, by Diane Carey. She is one of my favorite Star Trek authors. It is the story of James T. Kirk’s first adventure in space - as a sixteen year old, his coming of age story. It is told in tandem with a story at the close of Kirk’s career, alongside his long-time comrades and friends, Spock and McCoy.
The story opens with “Jimmy” Kirk, sixteen, leading a “gang” of friends on a run away adventure. He is routinely likened to a brat, thug, gangster, etc. - a teenager without direction, bucking the system. His father, George Kirk, his often off-planet serving in Starfleet Security. Jimmy is bitter about this; he thinks his father has abandoned his family for an easier, care-free life.
Through the events in the story, Jimmy Kirks realizes the worth in his father’s work and in Star Fleet as a whole. He sees how “crews” will live and die for each other, how they fight/explore/work for the greater good, and how they have all learned their place - their best destiny.
George Kirk enlists the help of his friend, the first Captain of the Starship Enterprise: Robert April. April helps George see Jimmy Kirk in a new light. At one point George sighs, “Jimmy is such a brat.” and April replies, “Ah, but he’s such a wonderful brat.” He further explains how the great ones are often unruly!
The parallel story has Jim Kirk second guessing his career, but his friends help him remember the lessons of that first adventure. The novel really captures the sense of camaraderie that has always attracted me to the world of Star Trek. Everyone has a place. Everyone does what he or she is gifted to do… and they do it in harmony with the rest of the crew. Everyone is encouraged to grow and learn. Everyone is a part of the team.
In the foreword, the authors ask the question, “What events in the life of Kirk gave him that extra pinch of determination and guile? What minor events and twists of fate resulted in Captain Kirk rather than Chief Surveyor Kirk, or Sixth Level Accountant Kirk, or Mr. J. T. Kirk, 101 No Particular Avenue? Best Destiny explores a pivetal moment in Kirk’s life.
It opens with these quotes:
What you from your fathers have inherited,
Earn it, in order to possess it. - Goethe
Commanding a starship is you first best destiny. Spock to Kirk, ST II: The Wrath of Khan
KIRK: My ship is gone. My career is ending. Maybe this is my best destiny. My full circle. This is where itbegan… maybe this is where it’s meant to end.
McCOY: Spit in the eye of “meant to”, Jim, you always have before… why not this time?
KIRK: Of all the decisions I’ve made in my career… how many have been wrong - and I’ll never know? Have I done more harm than good in my life?
SPOCK: It is a classic error of military history. Overestimate and be timid, underestimate and be destroyed. All leaders march that line… all captains sail it. I have been content these many years to march that line at James Kirk’s shoulder.
